Why electricity prices go negative

In a growing number of hours — most often sunny middays — the wholesale price of electricity in parts of Europe falls below zero, and generators pay for the privilege of producing. The mechanics are simpler than they sound.

Figures from our day-ahead archive, updated through 16 November 2026.

The auction is allowed to clear below zero

Wholesale electricity is priced a day in advance, in a coordinated European auction that closes at noon. Sellers submit offers, buyers submit bids, and the exchange finds the price at which supply meets demand for every delivery period of the following day. Nothing in that mechanism requires the answer to be positive: offers are accepted down to a floor of −500 €/MWh. When cheap supply exceeds what the grid can absorb, the price falls until enough sellers withdraw — and sometimes it has to fall below zero before they do.

That reluctance to switch off is the heart of the matter. Wind and solar plants on older support schemes are paid a fixed amount for every unit they generate, whatever the market does, so running at −20 €/MWh can still be worthwhile. Combined-heat-and-power stations have heat customers to serve. Large thermal units face shutdown and restart costs that can exceed the loss from a few negative hours. Each will pay to keep running, up to a point — and the clearing price shows exactly where that point sits.

Negative-price hours, 12 months
474 h
Germany (DE-LU)
Share of all hours
5.4%
same 12-month window
Lowest single hour
−499.0 €/MWh
past 12 months
Cheapest day on record
−53.9 €/MWh
daily average, 2 July 2023
Daily average day-ahead price in Germany (DE-LU), last 12 months, ranging from −16.3 €/MWh to 351.5 €/MWh. On 2 of 365 days the average across all 24 hours was below zero.

Where the hours cluster

Negative prices are a timing phenomenon, and the timing belongs to the weather. Solar output peaks at midday; demand does not. On a bright spring Sunday, when factories are quiet, a large solar fleet can push supply past everything the grid, exports and storage can take — so the below-zero hours concentrate between late morning and mid-afternoon, in the sunny half of the year, and above all on weekends and holidays. Windy nights and winter storms produce a second, smaller cluster, since wind does not keep office hours.

The pattern shows clearly across the markets that built renewables fastest. Over the past twelve months our archive counts 474 negative-price hours in Germany, 405 in the Netherlands and 761 in Spain — three systems where solar and wind capacity has grown faster than the flexibility to absorb it. You can put any of these markets side by side in the comparison tool.

Who ends up paying

A negative price is not free energy so much as a bill for missing flexibility, and it lands unevenly. Producers without subsidy protection simply lose money in those hours. In Germany the exposure sharpened in early 2025: new solar installations now forfeit their support payment during any period in which the price is negative, so an operator’s revenue depends on hours it does not control and cannot perfectly predict.

On the other side of the trade sit batteries, pumped hydro, electrolysers and anyone able to shift consumption — for them, a negative hour is an invitation. Households on dynamic tariffs are occasionally paid to run the dishwasher. In the long run the hours are self-limiting: they are precisely the signal that makes storage and flexible demand worth building, and every unit built absorbs a little more of the surplus that created them.